GeistHaus

Patterns

Why Do I Cry When Someone Is Kind to Me?

You can get through a hard week without tears. Bad news, a sharp email, a long day at the hospital: you manage. Then someone says something kind, asks how you are and actually waits for the answer, or tells you that you have done well, and your eyes fill before you can stop them. It can feel embarrassing and out of proportion, and it happens at films too, not at the sad part but at the reunion at the end. It is a common experience, and it makes more sense than it seems.

What It Looks Like From Inside

What Might Be Going On

Several of these may be true at once; the only person who can tell which is you.

It is finally safe to feel what you were holding.
Joseph Weiss, writing about why people cry at the happy ending, argued that tears come when it becomes safe to feel a sadness that had been held back (Weiss, 1952). While the danger lasts, the feeling waits; when the reunion comes, it can arrive. Kindness works the same way. It tells some part of you that the hard part is over, at least for a moment, and what was held back can come out.
Kindness reaches the place where it was missing.
When you are given something you went without for a long time, the gift and the lack arrive together. A kind word can bring with it an awareness of how rarely you heard one. Diana Fosha described this grief for what one did not get as mourning the self, and counted it among the feelings that come when things change for the better (Fosha, 2000). See mourning and loss.
Being received is a feeling of its own.
Fosha noticed that people often cry at the moment they take in someone else’s understanding, and read the tears as a sign of being seen and letting it in (Fosha, 2000). See the healing affects.
Coping has been doing all the work.
Some people get through hard times by staying practical and holding feeling off until later. Kindness is not a task, so it gives the coping nothing to do, and what was being held off arrives. See self-states.

The Exceptions

Most people who cry at kindness can also take some kindness without tears: from certain people, about certain things, on certain days. The difference is worth noticing. Often the kindness that undoes you is the kind that touches something specific, such as being told you did well by someone whose opinion matters, or being asked how you are by someone who seems to want the real answer. That is a clue to what was missing.

Where This Leads

Sources