Feelings That Transform
Some feelings go somewhere. A person cries hard about a death, and an hour later is tired, clearer, and oddly lighter. Other feelings go nowhere. A person goes over the same failure every night for a month, and each time it is as heavy as the first. Both are strong, and both hurt, but they are not the same kind of thing, and what helps one makes the other worse.
Diana Fosha, who developed accelerated experiential-dynamic psychotherapy (AEDP), built her approach on this difference (Fosha, 2000). She called the first kind core affect: a specific feeling, such as grief, anger, fear or joy, felt in the body and allowed to run its course. This page explains how it differs from the feelings that keep people stuck, why feeling something fully tends to leave a person with more rather than less, and why the sense of being out of control usually belongs to something else.
Core Ideas
- A core feeling has an end. It rises, crests and settles. It is about something in particular, and it is felt in the body.
- A stuck feeling circles. Self-attack, helplessness and “what’s the point” go round without arriving anywhere, and going deeper into them makes them worse.
- Feeling something fully leaves you with more. On the far side of a grief or an anger that ran its course, people tend to find relief, clarity and a sense of what to do.
- The out-of-control part is usually anxiety. What makes a feeling seem unbearable is often the fear of it, mixed in, rather than the feeling itself.
- Feelings are harder alone. Fosha argued that what makes many emotions unbearable is having to feel them without anyone there, and that much of what people do to avoid feeling was learned in that situation.
A Feeling That Runs and One That Circles
A core feeling has a shape. It starts with something specific, a loss, an injustice, a threat, and it is felt somewhere: a tight throat, heat in the face, a weight in the chest. Left to run, it builds, peaks and then eases, often within minutes. Fosha saw each core emotion as carrying an action it is built for: grief lets go, anger sets a limit, fear gets away, joy reaches toward (Fosha, 2000). When the feeling finishes, the action is often available in a way it was not before.
The feelings that keep people stuck look different. They are global rather than specific (“everything is wrong,” “I always ruin it”). They tend to be about the self rather than about what happened. They repeat instead of building, and they do not settle; each round leaves the person where they started, or a little lower. Some of them are what Fosha called defensive affects: feeling that stands in for a harder feeling, such as tears that come instead of anger, or irritation that comes instead of hurt. Others are what she called signal affects, mainly anxiety and shame, which register that a feeling is dangerous rather than being the feeling (see red lights and green lights).
The difference matters because the right response to each is opposite. A feeling that is running needs room and no interruption. A feeling that is circling needs steadying first: slowing down, getting specific, finding what it is about. Pressing a circling feeling deeper, in the hope that it will finally break, mostly produces more of it.
Why Feeling It Fully Leaves You With More
People often avoid a grief or an anger because they expect it to take something from them: their composure, their functioning, their sense of themselves as someone who copes. When the feeling is let all the way through, the experience is usually the reverse. Fosha described what comes after as a state of relief, calm and clarity, often with a new sense of what matters and what to do next (Fosha, 2000). Someone who has finally grieved a parent may find that they can speak about them with warmth for the first time. Someone who has let themselves be angry may find that the anger has turned into a plain, workable sentence: “I am not doing that again.”
The same idea runs through older psychoanalysis. Freud’s first cases turned on feelings that had never been felt, and on what changed when they were (Breuer & Freud, 1895). What later writers added is that the release itself is not the point. A feeling that is discharged and then forgotten changes little. A feeling that is felt, and then understood, becomes part of what the person knows about themselves.
The Out-of-Control Feeling
Many people say they cannot let themselves cry because they would never stop, or cannot let themselves be angry because they do not know what they would do. The fear is real. What it describes, though, is usually not the grief or the anger but the anxiety wrapped around it: the racing heart, the shaky breath, the sense of falling. David Malan’s triangle of conflict puts it simply: a feeling, the anxiety the feeling sets off, and the defense that keeps both out of sight (Malan, 1979). Leigh McCullough called the pattern an affect phobia, a learned fear of one’s own feelings that works like any other phobia (McCullough et al., 2003). See what a defense is afraid of.
Seen this way, the feeling that seems out of control is a mixture. When the anxiety is calmed, the feeling underneath is often smaller and more bearable than expected, and it has an end. That is also why a feeling that is flooding someone is not one to deepen: the flood is mostly the anxiety, and the first job is to bring it down.
Why It Is Harder Alone
Fosha’s central clinical idea is that emotions become unbearable when they have to be felt alone (Fosha, 2000). A child who is overwhelmed and finds no one there learns to stop feeling; a child who is overwhelmed and finds someone who stays learns that feelings end. Her approach to therapy was built around undoing that aloneness: a therapist who is openly present, who helps the person stay with what they feel, and who does not flinch from it. The same idea is behind John Bowlby’s secure base (Bowlby, 1988): what lets a person explore frightening territory is knowing that someone has their back.
A listener who is not a person can offer only part of this. It can notice, remember, and not flinch. It is not company, and it should not pretend to be. See not alone with it.
Examples
These are composite vignettes, not real people.
The Night She Finally Cried
For a year after her brother’s death, Leah talked about him only in the past tense and only in facts. One evening, writing about his old jacket, she stopped and cried for twenty minutes. Afterward she wrote that she was exhausted and that, for the first time, she wanted to call his daughter. The feeling had run, and on the far side of it was something to do.
The Same Thought Every Night
Tom lost a contract in March. By May he was still replaying it every night, each time ending with “I’m just not good enough for this.” Nothing new came up in the replays, and they never ended anywhere. When he was asked what exactly he had been afraid of in the meeting, the circling stopped for a minute, and he wrote something new: that the client had reminded him of his father.
Afraid of Her Own Anger
Maria says she does not get angry, because when she does she “loses it.” Asked what losing it looks like, she describes a pounding heart, a hot face and the urge to leave the room. She has never shouted at anyone. What she calls anger is mostly the alarm that goes off before it.
Sources
- Bowlby, J. (1988). A Secure Base. Routledge.
- Breuer, J., & Freud, S. (1895). Studies on hysteria. Standard Edition, 2.
- Fosha, D. (2000). The Transforming Power of Affect: A Model for Accelerated Change. Basic Books.
- Malan, D. H. (1979). Individual Psychotherapy and the Science of Psychodynamics. Butterworths.
- McCullough, L., Kuhn, N., Andrews, S., Kaplan, A., Wolf, J., & Hurley, C. L. (2003). Treating Affect Phobia: A Manual for Short-Term Dynamic Psychotherapy. Guilford Press.