Red Lights and Green Lights
Some feelings are less about what happened than about where you are. A knot of anxiety before you speak, a flush of shame halfway through a sentence: these are readings, taken in a fraction of a second, that this is not a safe place to go on. Their opposites are readings too. A flicker of hope, a moment of curiosity, the sense that you could say the next thing: these say that here, for now, it might be all right.
Diana Fosha called the first kind red signal affects and the second kind green signal affects (Fosha, 2000). Neither is the feeling that matters most in a given moment. They are the signals about whether that feeling can come out. This page explains both, why people tend to trust the red ones and take back the green ones, and what is lost when they do.
Core Ideas
- Some feelings are signals. Anxiety, shame and a certain kind of pain report on the situation: whether it is safe to feel and say what you feel.
- Red lights stop things. They shut down a feeling before it is felt, often before you know it was there.
- Green lights open things. Hope, curiosity, trust and relief say that something more is possible here.
- Green lights get taken back. They are quiet, they feel exposed, and many people learned early that hope is the thing that gets punished.
- The green ones matter as much as the red. A moment of hope that is noticed and kept is something to build on.
The Red Lights
Freud came to see anxiety as a signal: a small dose of fear that warns the mind of a danger and sets its defenses going (Freud, 1926). The danger is usually not outside. It is a feeling, a wish or a memory that once brought trouble, and the anxiety arrives just as it starts to surface. David Malan drew this as a triangle: the feeling, the anxiety it sets off, and the defense that follows (Malan, 1979). Shame works the same way. Silvan Tomkins described it as the affect that interrupts interest and enjoyment, checking a person mid-reach (Tomkins, 1963), and Donald Nathanson showed how much of social life is organized around avoiding that check (Nathanson, 1992). See shame and guilt.
Fosha’s point was that these feelings are not the problem in themselves. Often they are accurate reports about the past: in some earlier room, with some earlier person, a particular feeling was not welcome. The trouble is that the report keeps being filed in rooms where it is no longer true. A red light goes on when you start to tell a friend you are hurt, and you change the subject before you have noticed that you were about to say it.
Sometimes, though, the red light is about now. Fear or shame around a partner, a family member or anyone who threatens, controls or belittles you may be an accurate reading of the present room, and the first question then is whether you are safe, not where the feeling came from. Our safety page says where to start.
The Green Lights
Fosha’s more unusual contribution was to take the opposite signals as seriously (Fosha, 2000). When a person feels safe enough, small signs of it show: a looser tone, a joke, a flicker of hope, curiosity about something they would normally avoid, a sentence that starts “I’ve never said this, but.” These are readings that the room is good enough for something more. Attachment researchers describe the same thing from the outside: a child who feels the secure base behind them starts to explore (Bowlby, 1988).
Green lights are easy to miss because they are quiet. Anxiety interrupts; hope tends to murmur. A person in distress may show a green light for a second and then go back to the problem, and a listener who is focused on the problem goes with them.
Why Green Lights Get Taken Back
Many people hear their own hope as foolish. They report that something felt different, and then add, in the same breath, “probably nothing,” or “I’m being silly,” or “I know it won’t last.” The retraction is protective. For someone whose hopes were often disappointed, or mocked, a hope said aloud is a hope that can be taken away, and saying it is silly first gets ahead of the blow. Control-mastery theory would add that the retraction can be a test: will this listener agree that it was nothing? (Weiss, 1993).
When the retraction is accepted, the moment is lost. When it is gently left alone and the moment is kept, something different happens: the person has said a hopeful thing and it was not taken from them. Over time, that is part of how hope becomes less dangerous to say.
Examples
These are composite vignettes, not real people.
The Subject That Changes Itself
Every time Sam starts to write about his marriage, he ends up writing about work. He has not noticed the pattern. What he does notice, when it is pointed out, is a tightness in his chest each time the marriage comes up, which goes away as soon as he is back on the subject of his manager.
“Probably Nothing”
Nadia writes that she had coffee with her sister and, for an hour, did not feel like the difficult one. Then: “Probably nothing. We’ll be back to normal by Christmas.” The second sentence came so quickly that the first almost disappeared.
A Joke on a Bad Day
Ben has been low for weeks. In the middle of describing another bad morning, he makes a dry joke about his cat, the first in a long time. It is a small thing. It is also the first sign in a month that some part of him is looking outward.
Sources
- Bowlby, J. (1988). A Secure Base. Routledge.
- Fosha, D. (2000). The Transforming Power of Affect: A Model for Accelerated Change. Basic Books.
- Freud, S. (1926). Inhibitions, symptoms and anxiety. Standard Edition, 20.
- Malan, D. H. (1979). Individual Psychotherapy and the Science of Psychodynamics. Butterworths.
- Nathanson, D. L. (1992). Shame and Pride: Affect, Sex, and the Birth of the Self. Norton.
- Tomkins, S. S. (1963). Affect Imagery Consciousness: Vol. 2. The Negative Affects. Springer.
- Weiss, J. (1993). How Psychotherapy Works: Process and Technique. Guilford Press.