Why Can’t I Take a Compliment?
Someone says you did a good job, or that you look well, or that what you said helped, and before it has finished landing you have pushed it away: “oh, it was nothing,” “anyone would have,” “you’re just being nice.” Sometimes you change the subject. Sometimes you find the flaw they missed and point it out. Later you might replay the moment and wish you had just said thank you, and the next time it happens you do the same thing again. Criticism you can take. Something good is harder.
What It Looks Like From Inside
- A compliment produces a small jolt of discomfort, closer to embarrassment than to pleasure.
- You correct it at once: it was luck, it was the team, it was not as good as it looked.
- You suspect a motive. They want something, or they are being kind because they feel sorry for you.
- Praise in public is worse than praise in private, and praise for who you are is worse than for what you did.
- You remember one critical remark for months and forget ten kind ones by the weekend.
- Occasionally a compliment gets through, and what comes is not pleasure but a lump in the throat, or a sadness you cannot explain.
What Might Be Going On
Several of these may be true at once; the only person who can tell which is you.
- It does not match the picture.
- People tend to prefer feedback that confirms how they already see themselves, even when that view is negative. In William Swann’s studies, people with poor views of themselves often chose to interact with someone who saw them the same way, because being seen as they saw themselves felt safer than being seen kindly (Swann, Stein-Seroussi & Giesler, 1992). A compliment that does not fit the picture is unsettling, so it gets corrected.
- Good things feel unfamiliar.
- Diana Fosha noticed that for people used to being overlooked, being seen accurately and appreciated can be as unsettling as being criticized, because it is new (Fosha, 2000). What is familiar feels safe, even when it is bad, and what is good but unfamiliar feels like a trick. The discomfort says less about the compliment than about how rarely you have had one you could believe.
- Having shows up the not-having.
- Taking in something good can bring with it an awareness of how long you went without it. A person who was rarely praised as a child may find that real praise as an adult hurts in a way they did not expect: it touches the place where it was missing. Fosha called the grief that comes with this mourning the self (see mourning and loss). Waving the compliment off keeps that grief away.
- You run on a belief about what you deserve.
- “If people really knew me, they would not say that.” “Getting noticed is dangerous.” “Pride comes before a fall.” These are pathogenic beliefs in Joseph Weiss’s sense: convictions learned early that make a good thing feel like a mistake to be corrected (Weiss, 1993). Control-mastery theory adds that people test such beliefs, and that a belief loosens a little each time the test is passed.
- Being seen is exposing.
- A compliment puts you at the center of attention, and for some people attention itself is the problem. Shame can be triggered by pleasure as easily as by failure: Silvan Tomkins thought shame interrupts interest and enjoyment, and Donald Nathanson that pride and shame are closely linked (Tomkins, 1963; Nathanson, 1992). See shame and guilt.
The Exceptions
Almost everyone who waves off compliments has taken one in at some point. From one person, about one thing, on a day when they were too tired to argue. The exceptions are worth looking at: who it was easiest to believe, what they said and how, and what it felt like when it got through. Often it was a compliment that was said as a plain fact rather than as praise, by someone who did not seem to need anything back.
Where This Leads
- The healing affects, on what it feels like when something good does land.
- Envy and gratitude, on the capacity to take in something good and feel enriched by it.
- Why do I cry when someone is kind to me?, the same difficulty when the kindness gets through.
- Why does criticism wreck me for days?, the other side of the same scale.
- Pathogenic beliefs, on the convictions that make a good thing feel like a mistake.
Sources
- Fosha, D. (2000). Meta-therapeutic processes and the affects of transformation: Affirmation and the healing affects. Journal of Psychotherapy Integration, 10(1), 71–97.
- Nathanson, D. L. (1992). Shame and Pride: Affect, Sex, and the Birth of the Self. Norton.
- Swann, W. B., Jr., Stein-Seroussi, A., & Giesler, R. B. (1992). Why people self-verify. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 62(3), 392–401.
- Tomkins, S. S. (1963). Affect Imagery Consciousness: Vol. 2. The Negative Affects. Springer.
- Weiss, J. (1993). How Psychotherapy Works: Process and Technique. Guilford Press.