GeistHaus

Inner Life

The Healing Affects

Most writing about feelings is about the painful ones. But there is a family of feelings that shows up when something goes right: feeling moved, feeling lighter, gratitude, a quiet pride, the tears that come when someone says a kind thing and it actually lands. They tend to arrive at the moment something changes, and they tend to be gone again by the next week, often without anyone having said a word about them.

Diana Fosha called this family the affects of transformation, and argued that they are not a pleasant side effect of change but part of how it happens (Fosha, 2000a, 2000b). This page describes them, the forms they take, and why a good moment that is noticed and named lasts longer than one that is let go.

Core Ideas

What They Are

Fosha described three kinds (Fosha, 2000b). The first are the feelings of having done something hard: joy, pride, a sense of strength or mastery after a feeling has been let through or a step has been taken. The second is a particular grief, which she called mourning the self: sorrow for what one went through, or did not get, felt with compassion for oneself rather than as a complaint (see mourning and loss). The third are the feelings of receiving: being moved when someone understands, gratitude, tenderness toward the person who helped. These are the ones she named the healing affects. This page uses her name for the third kind as a name for the whole family, because it is the one most people recognize.

The tears that come when something kind lands belong to this last kind. Many people are surprised by them. They can cry at a criticism without much feeling, and then find themselves undone by a sentence of plain recognition. Fosha read those tears as a sign that something long expected not to happen has just happened: the person has been seen, and has let it in. She called the experience of taking in another person’s understanding receptive affective experience, and thought it as important as being able to express what one feels (see the alliance).

Receiving Affirmation

For many people the hardest thing to receive is something good about themselves. A compliment is deflected with a joke, thanks are waved away, praise is explained as the other person being kind. Melanie Klein thought the capacity to take in something good, and feel enriched rather than diminished by it, was one of the central achievements of a life (Klein, 1957; see envy and gratitude). Fosha saw the same difficulty from a different angle: for someone used to being overlooked, being seen accurately can be as unsettling as being criticized, because it does not fit what they expect.

When the affirmation does get in, the healing affects follow: often a pause, a softening, sometimes tears. It is worth slowing down for. It is also worth not overdoing; a person who is flooded with praise tends to deflect it all. See why can’t I take a compliment? and why do I cry when someone is kind to me?

Why the Good Moment Disappears

Bad experiences tend to outweigh good ones of the same size. They are noticed more, remembered longer, and weigh more in how people judge their lives (Baumeister, Bratslavsky, Finkenauer & Vohs, 2001). A hard conversation can be replayed for a week; an hour in which something eased is usually gone by the weekend. Barbara Fredrickson’s research on positive emotions suggests that what they do is widen what a person can notice and try, and that the effect builds when they recur (Fredrickson, 2001). Neither happens to a moment that passed without being noticed.

Fosha’s answer was to stop and look at the moment itself. She called it meta-therapeutic processing: asking, right after something has shifted, what it is like to have had that shift (Fosha, 2000b). What is it like to have said that out loud? What is it like to hear it said back? She found that the questions tend to produce more of the same feelings rather than using them up, and that what is found there, put into words, becomes something the person can return to later.

Examples

These are composite vignettes, not real people.

The Sentence That Landed

Carla has described her years of looking after her mother many times, always as logistics. One evening she writes that a nurse told her she had done a remarkable job, and that she had to go and sit in the car because she could not stop crying. She does not know why it hit so hard. It is the first time anyone has said it.

Lighter, and Then Back to Work

Owen finishes explaining a falling-out with a friend and writes, “Huh. That actually feels lighter.” In the next sentence he asks what he should do about the friend. The lighter feeling is never mentioned again, and a week later he does not remember that it happened.

Grief for a Childhood

Writing about her father’s drinking, June stops arguing about whether he could have done better and writes instead that she was a little girl who needed someone and nobody came. She says it is sad, and that it is also the first time she has felt sorry for herself without feeling pathetic about it.

Sources