GeistHaus

Object Relations

The One Who Was in Your Corner

Ask people about the hard parts of their childhood and they can usually tell you a great deal. Ask them whether there was anyone they could be themselves with, and many say no at first. Then, after a pause, someone turns up: a grandmother who let them help in the kitchen, a teacher who read their stories aloud, a neighbor, an older cousin, a dog. The person was there all along. They just did not belong to the story the person usually tells.

This page is about that person: the exception in the pattern, the relationship in which you could feel what you felt and be who you were. It explains why one such relationship is enough to build on, why people tend to believe there was none until someone asks, and what remembering it can do.

Core Ideas

Why One Is Enough

Emmy Werner and Ruth Smith followed every child born on the Hawaiian island of Kauai in 1955 for decades. Many grew up in poverty, with family conflict or parental illness, and a third of those high-risk children did well as adults anyway. One of the things that set them apart was at least one close, steady relationship with an adult who cared about them, often not a parent: a grandparent, an aunt, a teacher (Werner & Smith, 1992). Later resilience research came to the same conclusion so often that Ann Masten called resilience “ordinary magic”: it rests mostly on common human resources, close relationships with caring adults among them (Masten, 2001). See adaptation and resilience.

Attachment research has its own version. Some adults describe difficult childhoods yet tell the story coherently and parent securely themselves, and other relationships, alongside the hard ones or later in life, are part of how that comes about (see attachment on earned security). Diana Fosha thought these relationships matter because they leave a trace of a different configuration of self and other, one in which the person could feel and be known, and that this trace is something to build on rather than something to explain away (Fosha, 2000). See self at worst, self at best.

Why People Believe There Was No One

The usual story of a life is organized around the thing that hurt. That is reasonable; it is the part that needs explaining. But it means the exceptions get filed elsewhere, and after enough retellings they stop being part of the account. Mood plays a part as well: in a low state, memories that fit the state come more easily than those that do not, and a person who is down when asked may honestly find nothing (see self-states).

There is also a kind of loyalty to the hard story. Remembering that a grandmother was kind can feel, oddly, like letting the people who were not off the hook, or like admitting that things were not as bad as one has always said. They were as bad as one has always said. The grandmother was also kind. A plain question, asked once, without any pressure to find someone, is often what lets the person come back into view.

What Remembering Can Do

The person in your corner is evidence. They show that you were, at least once, someone who could be liked as you were, and that you could feel safe enough to be yourself. For someone whose self-at-worst runs on the belief that no one could stand them, that is not a small thing. It is also a guide: what was it about that person that made the difference, and is there anyone like that now?

Remembering them is not meant to soften what went wrong elsewhere. A kind teacher does not make up for a frightening parent. The two belong to different parts of the story, and both parts are real.

Examples

These are composite vignettes, not real people.

The Kitchen

Asked whether there was anyone he could be himself with as a boy, Tom says no, then mentions that he spent most Saturdays at his grandmother’s, rolling out pastry. She never asked him how school was. He says he had not thought about it in years, and that it is strange how much better he feels for remembering it.

The Music Teacher

Aisha describes herself as the difficult child in a house where nobody listened. Weeks later, in passing, she mentions the music teacher who let her stay late and never once called her difficult. She is surprised to realize that the teacher is the reason she still plays.

Sources