Self at Worst, Self at Best
Everyone has a version of themselves that turns up when things go badly. It is smaller, more frightened or more defended, it expects the worst of other people, and from inside it, it feels like the truth. Everyone also has a version that turns up when things go well: steadier, more curious, able to feel what there is to feel and still think. Most people know the first one far better than the second, and many would not believe you if you told them the second was just as real.
Diana Fosha called these the self-at-worst and the self-at-best configurations (Fosha, 2000). Each is more than a mood. It is a whole arrangement: who you are, who the other person seems to be, and which feelings are available to you while you are in it. This page describes both, and why a bad state is a state rather than a verdict.
Core Ideas
- Everyone has both. No one is only their worst state, and no one lives permanently in their best.
- Each comes with an other. The worst state usually has someone critical, absent or frightening in it. The best state usually has someone who sees you clearly.
- Each comes with its own feelings. In the worst state, anxiety and shame crowd out everything else. In the best, the full range is available.
- A bad state is a state, not a verdict. What feels like the truth about you from inside it is one configuration among others.
- The best state is worth knowing in detail. When you are at your worst, it is the most useful thing to remember, and the hardest.
The Two Configurations
Fosha drew each configuration as a triangle of self, other and feeling (Fosha, 2000). In the self-at-worst, the self is helpless, bad or alone; the other is rejecting, critical, intrusive or simply not there; and the feelings are the ones that signal danger, mostly anxiety and shame, together with whatever defenses keep the rest out of sight. It is often the configuration a person learned in the hardest parts of their early life, and it returns, years later, whenever something rhymes with those times.
In the self-at-best, the self is capable, open and real; the other is someone who is attuned and helpful, whom Fosha called the true other, after Winnicott’s true self (Winnicott, 1960); and the feelings that are available are the core ones, grief, anger, joy, love, felt and bearable. This configuration also has a history. It is built from whoever, at some point, was good to the person: a grandparent, a teacher, a friend, a partner, sometimes a stranger.
The idea is close to Mardi Horowitz’s states of mind, each organized around a model of how self and other will behave (Horowitz, 1987), and to the reciprocal roles of cognitive analytic therapy (Ryle & Kerr, 2002). What Fosha added was a deliberate attention to the good configuration, which clinical writing had mostly left out. See self-states.
Who You Are With
The most revealing part of each configuration is often the other person in it. People can usually say, if asked, who they are at their best with: “With my sister I don’t have to hold it together.” “On the boat with my uncle I could think.” The other person in that sentence is not always someone in their life now. It may be someone long gone, or someone they met once. What matters is that the configuration exists, and that the person can describe it in their own words. See the one who was in your corner.
The worst state has its people too, though they are often harder to name. A critical inner voice usually has a source. A sudden collapse in front of a manager may have less to do with the manager than with the person the manager resembles. See internal objects.
A State, Not a Verdict
From inside the worst state, it is very hard to remember that any other state exists. That is part of what makes it the worst: it brings its own certainty. People in it say “this is who I really am” and believe it, and they discount every good memory as a time they were fooling themselves or others. Then, a week later, the state lifts, and they find it hard to remember how bad it felt.
Neither state is the real one. Both are real. Knowing that one is in a configuration rather than seeing the truth at last is often the first step toward getting out of it. And knowing the other configuration in detail, who is in it, what it feels like, what becomes possible, gives the worst state something to be measured against.
Examples
These are composite vignettes, not real people.
Two Versions of One Woman
When her manager criticizes her, Imani goes silent, apologizes for things that are not hers, and spends the evening sure she is about to be fired. When she is coaching the junior staff, she is funny, quick and sure of herself. She describes the first as the real her and the second as an act. Asked when she last felt that the coaching version was the act, she cannot remember.
“With Him I Could Think”
Paul mentions, in passing, that the only time he ever felt clever was in the year he spent working for an old carpenter who explained everything twice and never raised his voice. He has never connected it to anything. He says it in the middle of a bad week, and then goes back to the bad week.
Sources
- Fosha, D. (2000). The Transforming Power of Affect: A Model for Accelerated Change. Basic Books.
- Horowitz, M. J. (1987). States of Mind: Configurational Analysis of Individual Psychology (2nd ed.). Plenum.
- Ryle, A., & Kerr, I. B. (2002). Introducing Cognitive Analytic Therapy: Principles and Practice. Wiley.
- Winnicott, D. W. (1960). Ego distortion in terms of true and false self. In The Maturational Processes and the Facilitating Environment (1965, pp. 140–152). Hogarth Press.