Show full content
By Libby Kurz

Last summer, my husband asked (once again!) if I’d join a 2v2 beach volleyball league with him. I was the only member of our family of five who didn’t play, and I’d been reluctant to join an activity where I’d clearly be the worst one. Surprising us all, however, I relented.
As soon as I stepped on the court, a voice in my mind got to work on me: You’re a forty-five- year-old mom, what do you think you’re doing? Silently judging others from the sidelines had been so much more fun. I’d hoped my family’s advanced skills might magically osmose through my body after years of watching them play, but instead, I was chasing my shanked balls across the beach and scolded by the opposing team for messing up the score.
The assumption in midlife is that we should just know how to do things. Amid the daily responsibilities of work, parenting, or scrubbing dog vomit off the family room rug, it can feel absurd to try something new. But starting from zero brought an unexpected, albeit humbling, sense of freedom, and I wondered what would happen if I applied this to other areas of my life— particularly my writing.
I completed my MFA over a decade ago and have taken countless workshops since. I should know what I’m doing by now, right? But as journalist Stephen Marche shares, one of the great paradoxes of writing is that the more we do it, the harder it is and the more we will fail. “The public sees writers mainly in their victories,” he says, “but their lives are spent mostly in defeat.”
Marche tells the story of yet another writer, Nathan Englander, at dinner with Philip Roth. “Is it ever easier?” Englander asked Roth. “My skin will get thicker with each book, right?”
No, Roth replied. “It’ll get thinner and thinner until they can hold you up to the light and see through.”
A similar sense of defeat and exposure pervaded my own writing a few years ago, when I crossed from poetry to memoir, a notoriously rejected genre. Last summer, five years and four drafts into my manuscript, the project had proved more ponderous and vulnerable than anything I’d attempted. I was stuck.
But as my body trudged through sand each week, learning a new sport, I realized that if we need instruction as beginners, why wouldn’t we also need it once we’ve become proficient, committed players? After all, even professional athletes have coaches. And if this applies to a sport, how much truer must it be of writing, an artform that demands skill, endurance, and mortifying self-exposure? At risk of adding more humiliation to my life, I decided to hire a writing coach.
I’ve been working with my coach, Peter Mountford, for a few months now, and though it’s terrifying to receive feedback on chapters I’ve already spent years revising, the journey has instilled curiosity and joy back into my process. Brené Brown shares a similar realization in a recent NPR interview, in which she compares learning pickleball to her faith in God and how both things feel unreachable. “Who thought I’d ever become the student of a game again and never want to stop playing because you never get there?” I was reminded that amid my embarrassing mistakes and endless revisions, there’s a surprising sense of delight in trying to master what cannot be mastered.
William Faulkner told The Paris Review that the futility which defines the writing life is actually the healthiest state for a writer to live in. “All of us failed to match our dream of perfection,” he said. “So I rate us on the basis of our splendid failure to do the impossible.” Besides, if we finally surpassed the pinnacle of perfection, what would we have to work toward?
Each time I step on the volleyball court or continue editing my memoir manuscript, that accusing voice in my mind still crops up. But I’m learning that if I can trade the safety of the sidelines for the inevitability of failure, I open myself to the possibility of making contact with others in our messy, shared humanity. We will never achieve perfection, but what might happen if we try?
There were moments this past summer when I paused between points, marveling as the setting sun illuminated our half-naked, sand-caked bodies, trying to keep a dumb ball afloat. At its core, volleyball is an effort to defy the ubiquitous force of gravity, which, in the end, always wins. The ball will drop, but amid each player’s futile attempt to keep it in play, we were connecting with ourselves, each other, and the vital energy of life itself. Our sunlit skin was so thin you could almost see through.
________
Libby Kurz is a writer, RN, and military veteran. She’s the author of a poetry chapbook, The Heart Room, and her work has appeared in The Iowa Review and elsewhere. She lives in Virginia Beach with her husband, three teens, and 115lb. lap dog. She’s still revising her memoir. Find her on Instagram or her website.












